Cheryl Donegan
“Female Heroism: One Portrayal, Four Portraits,” Tema Celeste (November/December, 1992)
The film “The Silence of the Lambs” begins with
a woman running. Clarise Starling (Jodie Foster) is traversing
the training course at the F.B.I. Academy. Sweating, panting,
she crashes through the brush to rising music. In this scenario,
contradictory readings emerge. An image of a woman running
becomes an image of a woman being chased. Victim fantasies
are activated. We almost begin to root for her to get away.
The revelry is snapped by the appearance of a rope ladder.
Clarise is back o the training course, secure on F.B.I. turf – her
only assailants, the competing harrions: Fatigue and ambition.
This brief sequence foreshadows many overlapping themes and
events in the film: the hunter and hunted (Clarise runs both
from and towards things), the labyrinth or obstacle course,
and the process of transformation (from neophyte to initiate).
During her transformation from student to hero Clarise must
travel a twisting path through real dungeons and basements
into the depths of her own memory while amassing the clues
to her revelation.
In her recent installation at American Fine Arts Gallery,
Jessica Stockholder turns the house inside out and sends you
in to look for something. She turns the house inside out, exposing
the beams and seams, the work of nails and needles. Raw wooden
beams crisscross the space muscularly – but the piece
does not seem muscle bound. There is an awareness of impermanence
and vulnerability – like a fort made of upended lawn
furniture and blankets. Two sofa cushions creep up a pole,
clinging there above the fray, subtly anthropomorphizing the
column. It becomes a contemporary caryatid – skinny as
a rail with gigantic breast implants.
The installation exists somewhere between a barn-raising and
a house-wrecking. It is a site of transition and transformation.
There is no privileged point of view in the piece – no
best vantage point. To understand it requires a journey through
it. Around the walls, behind the curtains, hides the core of
the piece – rows of stacked cardboard boxes. You get
the feeling the artist could come in here any minute and extend
the installation – rip open the cartons and add their
contents to the sprawl. Or, the boxes could contain objects
she’s packed away, secret items she doesn’t want
us to see. These mysterious, mute boxes make a striking juxtaposition
to the raucous collage of objects and materials around them.
Finding them is like coming upon a closed closet door at the
end of a maze of rooms. Have you the courage to look inside?
Do you really want to know?
Like other examples of her work, in this installation Stockholder’s
gestural manner with materials pushes her across boundaries
between mass and place, shape and surface. In her work, objects
get painted, “coverings” (carpets, cloth, linoleum)
get recovered, surfaces (walls, floors) get resurfaced (with
tape, paper mache, etc.) She calls our attention to “skins” – how
they can change, multiply, and interrupt the identities of
things. Emphasizing skins, Stockholder plays punningly with “hides”.
Her pieces, conglomerates of the scavenged, the bought, and
the hand wrought, are visual amalgams – multiple meanings
are wrung from the works as the viewer examines the scramble.
Stockholder’s installation is organized around sweeping
gestures and dramatic color notes that put one in mind of abstract
expressionist painting, or earlier, romantic history painting.
The installation could be described in these terms – bold
swipes of color and shape disgorge a loose-limbed narrative
in which one detects, discovers, and like a character in an
ancient Greek tale, gathers up bits of a fragmented self.
For Clarise the process of transformation requires equal parts
education and intuition. As she runs the gauntlet between Jack
Crawford, the head of Behavioral Sciences at the F.B.I., and
Hannibal Lector, “Hannibal-the-Cannibal,” the imprisoned
mad-genius who offers to help her, on her way to confronting
Buffalo Bill, a currently active serial killer, she learns
to balance calculation and spontaneity. Strict adherence to
the rules may deprive her of a chance for advancement; impulsive
action might alienate her from sources of power and knowledge.
Crawford, her F.B.I. mentor encourages her deductive skills
and powers of observation. Yet he can be subtly dismissive,
exclusive as to his agenda, even downright demeaning. In a
scene at a small town funeral home Crawford smoothes a local
sheriff’s rumpled ego, playing upon good old boy customs
at Clarise’s expense. She does not protest but takes
the rebuff, fuming. Later, her satisfaction comes as she hustles
the coffee-guzzling cops out of a room where she and other
agents will examine the body of Bill’s latest victim.
In her best West Virginia accent she drawls after them to “git
on outta here”, shooing them away like a pack of schoolboys.
Clarise has learned to pick her battles – sometimes,
courtesy gets one further than a curse. However, politeness
can be tinged with sarcasm – the note of condescension
she attaches to the word “sir” in addressing the
despicable Dr. Chilton, Lector’s keeper. She unlocks
the puzzling anagrams that Lector tosses at her, matches his
cunning with her own slipperiness. When she stumbles in his
snares she relies on frankness, catches him off guard with
her candidness.
“he, he” says the painting. The viewer hardly
knows whether this skittish laughter is prompted by a sense
of exhilaration or doom. The painting is by Suzanne McClelland,
whose raw but vigorously worked canvasses combine drawing,
painting, and writing, splattered paint and chunks of clay.
The words McClelland uses in her paintings evoke time-now,
someday, always. The surfaces of the paintings speak of process.
Although her works with words nervously scratched into spare
and spacey fields have been most compared with the works of
Cy Twombly, they are less sentimental and nostalgic. McClelland
is less a transcriber, invoking names associated with the glorious
past, than she is a marker of her own edicts. “Now,” written
bold, is a demand. “Always,” written backwards
and forwards is an oath that stretches from the past into the
future. “Someday,” is a shaky promise. Her words
do not site orderly upon the page—they float and scatter,
flip themselves over, multiply, bulge and shrink. Often it
is difficult to discern the words, to differentiate between
what is a letter and what is a random skein of paint, a smudge
of charcoal or a pool of acrylic medium. In this McClelland’s
work can be compared to the late work of Jackson Pollock. The
control he exerted over line – at times allowing it to
meander freely in space, at others roping it in to delineate
a form – seems analogous to McClelland’s vacillation
between chance and will.
In “he, he” McClelland disperses her chicken scratch
h’s and e’s all over the trop and down the sides
of the square canvas. Like giddy laughter the “he’s” roil
and tumble. Some of the letters are reversed, making it “eh,
eh” and giggles give way to a relentless humming and
hawing, in impediment to speech. Another glance and “he,
he” is not a joke at all. He is everywhere – it
makes one minds of the male omnipresence in painting. It challenges
one to consider what it is like to be young and female and
possessing a mostly male pantheon of artistic influences, of
being on the receiving end of that most backhanded or compliments – “she
paints like a man.”
The painting is not dominated be he’s, however. From
the bottom right, extending up into the center of the painting
McClelland has ignited a big white flash. This whiteout or
whitewash floods the work with light and air. It is simultaneously
rejuvenating and destructive – like Bataille’s
light which casts one into darkness, a blinding light. It washes
away the he’s, it laughs Shiva-like at the mayhem. It
is a cleansing light, but not virginal – testimony to
an ability of McClelland to make things delicate without making
them prissy, to make them elegant without smothering them in
taste.
In her paintings, McClelland fuses deeds and words, engages
the material and the spiritual. Looking on of her smeary encrusted
surfaces you take stock of what you are. Reading one of her
words reminds you of what you hope to become.
When calculation and deduction will not do, Clarise Starling
risks defiance. Instructed not to approach the glass of Lector’s
cell, she ignores the caution almost immediately and steps
up at Lector’s urging. She does not do this cavalierly,
however; her face is tense, she knows what is at stake when
she “rolls the dice.”
Clarise, like the serial killer she stalks, is covetous. Eager,
studious, ambitious, what she loves most is advancement. She
desires power and seeks knowledge. She identifies with the
powerful men around her – the cool professionalism of
Crawford, the “high-powered perception” of Lector.
She seeks confirmation from a male dominated society but, in
her questing, she does not ignore or discount her own experience
of the world. Clarise’s personal memories, however painful,
are a source of strength, comfort, and wisdom to her. Recalling
her father’s funeral she is reminded of how she survived
abandonment. Her familiarity with the culture of girlhood – glitter
nailpolish, pierced ears and jewelry boxes where secrets are
stashed, serve her in her detective work. She “knows” Buffalo
Bill’s victims. Like her they are Southern, small town,
white and female. Her empathy invigorates her hunt for the
victimizer. Clarise is, as Lector deduces, a “well-scrubbed,
hustling young rube with a bit of taste” whose dreams
take her beyond the world of her policeman father into the
realm of Fathers, the governmental organization, the Federal
Bureau of Investigation.
Lisa Hoke is the daughter of a Navy test pilot. She speaks
of a childhood spent earthbound with her mother and sister
while her father “flew around up there.” In her
artwork Hoke challenges her childhood condition.
Over the past five years Hoke has been hanging her pieces
from the ceiling. In her spare, elegant compositions of the
late eighties, Hoke suspended metal wire and cast iron objects
from the ceiling with exacting balance. Tautly controlled high
wire acts, these works called for the precision and daring
demanded when one puts natural laws like gravity to the test.
With aerodynamic pieces, Hoke hurtled through space; in her
more recent work, she hoists and hovers. Hoke is suspending
things that look like they were never meant to leave the ground.
In “Manifold Destiny” Hoke created a woven hanging
of car mufflers, exhaust pipes and plastic stripping from patio
furniture. A post-industrial Penelope, she plaits suburban
detritus and hangs it up like an emblem to bad vacations. In
Hoke’s corroded crochet, rusted snaky pipes writhe against
yellow and pink strips of plastic in a tableau of order and
chaos – a Medusa in curlers. The effect is both funny
and frightening.
Like the infamous tripping spider, Hoke weaves a tangled web.
She makes use of the mixed messages implied by hanging – it
is difficult to say for certain whether this piece is about
the magic of levitation, a magic carpet replete with charmed
snakes, or a banner to failure and defeat, plastic bonds squeezing
the life out of squirming, exhausted pipes. At once vulnerable
and menacing, fanciful and threatening, delicate and Herculean, “Manifold
Destiny” has many implications. Hoke tempts the void,
bravely dangles her objects above terra firma of fixed meanings.
The risks Clarise Starling assumes in tracking Buffalo Bill
culminate in her acceptance of Lector’s quid pro quo
deal – he will trade information about the killer in
exchange for access to Clarise’s most intimate childhood
memories. This bargain satisfies both their cravings. Clarise
wants to know what she suspects Lector knows. Lector wants
to devour, if only metaphorically, human innards. He is a shrink
after all. He craves to sample the ingredients of human souls,
to examine the emotional viscera. In Lector, however, this
desire is reified in a horrifying pathology – he is a
cannibal. He reminds Clarise that he kept no trophies (shrunken
heads) from his victims – “No,” she deadpans, “you
ate yours.”
Clarise takes this great risk, letter Lector inside her head,
because she believes in the stability of her inner core. He
may try to devour her, but he cannot dislodge her from her
spiritual center. She knows it too well, inhabits it too deeply.
Unlike James Gumm (Buffalo Bill’s real name) her attempts
at change are not motivated by self-loathing. Gumm wants to
remake himself, to reclothe his identity in a vestment of flayed
female skins. Attempting to destroy himself he must destroy
others. Clarise, although she identifies with others, does
not try to become them. Her “psychic sense of place” is
not compromised but is enhanced by the challenge she faces.
Lawre Stone makes multi-layered paintings composed of given
elements and chance operations. Her paintings begin with mottled
surfaces of stained and dripped paint. On to this ground, she
will sometimes hand write words. Then she drapes stencils onto
her canvasses and traces the spirals or flower shapes. When
the stencils are removed, thick oil color is swathed in the
interspersing shapes. The net effect are paintings whose dizzying
composition, aggressive paint handling and loud color make
them hard to love – and just as hard to ignore.
Stone’s sense of color and her feel for surface and
shape are as much incorporations of art history as expressions
of the tones and texture of a Seventies childhood. One sees
the eccentric surface and shape handlings of later Poons or
early Benglis, the wiggly bimorphs of Art or Elizabeth Murray,
the bright colors of Ree Morton or Wayne Theibaud. But Stone’s
aesthetic is shaped as well by the orange and hot pink interior
of Barbie’s Dream House and the swirling Op concoctions
of a Spirograph set.
In “Her Master’s Voice” Stone lays down
the voice of a Surrealist master – Andre Breton – extolling
the virtues of the movement’s muse Gala Uluard: “She
is a creature of grace and promise, close in her sensibility
and behavior to the two sacred worlds of childhood and madness.” Upon
the “foundation” of this eloquently stated, stereotypical
view of the nature of womanhood, Stone builds a spiraling composition.
New voices float up to the surface as the old sentiment is
muffles by layers of cakey paint. Words such as “he,” “she,” and “of
child” emerge. The beginning of “sacred” looks
like “scared” or “scarred.” “Her
sensibility” becomes “her sex.” Stone engages
Breton in a “he said/she said” dialogue. As a woman
seeking to engage and record her experiences with abstract
painting, a traditionally male dominated mode of expression,
Stone sees that it is vital to speak to, not only through,
its means. One way Stone has of doing this is to make her painting
evidence the turbulent feelings her ambitions bring. In her
whirlpools of paint, her centrifugal compositions and her heavily
stroked, garish color, Stone delights in the mingling of oil
and water. She is interested, not simply in turning the tables,
but in recording the spin.
In the story of the screaming lambs, Clarise recounts how
she – young, orphaned, a lost lamb herself – was
awakened by the human-sounding cries of the spring lambs prepared
for slaughter on her uncle’s ranch. In the valiant attempt
to save one lamb Clarise illustrated, with a child’s
guilelessness, her heroic nature. Early in life she revealed
an inclination to be a liberator and protector. Punished by
the rancher for her idealism, she did not abandon her ideals.
These ideas, embedded in her spiritual center, are the ones
that drive her in search of the serial killer.
Lector compels Clarise to expose through her story the kernel
of her being. What she finds there – her essential heroic
nature – gives her the strength and energy to attain
her goal. Like some infernal Wizard of Oz, Lector helps her
discover what she already possesses. It is her awareness of
and belief in this defining internal knowledge that enables
Clarise to learn from the men around her without become subservient
to them, to depend on their assistance without becoming reliant
upon them, to emerge fro her education with her own experience
of the world intact and at her service.
|