Roberta Smith
“Art in Review: Suzanne Mcclelland,” The New York Times (December 18, 1992)
Suzanne McClelland has avoided one of the signal problems
of installation art – that it often seems more staged
than made – by creating an emphatically hand-drawn and
hand-painted environment covering three walls and spilling
onto bits and pieces of drywall propped around the gallery.
This walk-in painting is executed in Ms. McClelland’s
characteristic style, in which letters and words emerge from
the chaos of an assured Abstract Expressionist-inspired gesturalism.
It has a terrific improvisational energy, something like a
good studio visit when a great deal of promising work is under
way. The floor, covered with paint-smeared cardboard, enhances
the impression that artistic activity may resume any second.
One takes in this word in extended visual bounces that send
the eye ricocheting from surface to surface, reading and looking,
sorting sense from nonsense. Study any scrawled mark or odd
painted shape long enough, and it usually metamorphoses into
a letter or word fragment. Eventually the word “Right” which
is the work’s title, emerges from the tumult, beginning
with waves of fat R’s in the far left corner, and culminating
in the end wall, a surging Pollock-style sea of G’s and
H’s. The fact that beneath their markings, the three
walls are painted red, white, and blue (in that order, left
to right) imparts political meaning to the work’s subject
and title – far right, civil right, human right. (the
show’s brochure confirms the association, noting that
the artist began formulating the piece during last summer’s
political conventions.)
The piece has its weak moments. In certain areas, it seems
as if some low-quality Abstract Expressionist painting has
simply escaped from its canvas; one starts wishing that Ms.
McClelland would really return and bring the entire effort
up to the level of its best parts. Nonetheless, the best parts,
stuttering and tumbling down and across the wall, are sustaining,
and the rest provides a rare window on the creative process. |